Property accessors resolved via SpEL's ReflectivePropertyAccessor and
DataBindingPropertyAccessor may be JavaBean-style accessors or plain
accessor methods used to support data classes such as Java records and
Kotlin data classes. However, neither accessor can determine, via
reflection, whether such a method is a side-effect-free read or an
action that happens to return a value. For example, File.delete() is a
public method that returns a boolean and therefore looks like a
plain "property".
To better inform users, this commit updates the Javadoc for
ReflectivePropertyAccessor, DataBindingPropertyAccessor, and
SimpleEvaluationContext (as well as in the SpEL reference
documentation) to clarify that restricting a SimpleEvaluationContext to
read-only data binding governs only whether assignment to a property is
permitted and does not guarantee that reading a property is free of
side effects. The reference documentation's "Security Considerations"
section now also defines what makes a method "accessor-shaped", with
concrete examples of safe versus side-effecting methods that share that
shape (for example, File.delete(), Queue.poll(), and
AtomicInteger.incrementAndGet()).
Building on that clarification, this commit introduces a new "Object
Design" section to the SpEL reference documentation, analogous to the
"Model Design" guidance for web data binding. This new section
recommends that any object reachable from an untrusted SpEL expression
(not only the root object) be a purpose-built, immutable type with a
deliberately limited surface area, and that its accessor-shaped methods
be audited for unsafe side effects. The new section also notes that
reachability is transitive through both property navigation and
indexing (for example, rootObject.child.grandchild or
rootObject.items[0]).
In any case, it remains the responsibility of the code that exposes a
root object or other reachable object to an expression from an
untrusted source to ensure that none of its accessor-shaped methods
perform an unsafe action.
Closes gh-37102
The Javadoc for EvaluationContext, StandardEvaluationContext, and
SimpleEvaluationContext previously repeated the same detailed
explanation of trusted sources and best-effort restrictions in four
places, making it hard to maintain and to digest.
This commit condenses each class-level warning to a succinct summary
that links to the new "Security Considerations" section of the SpEL
reference documentation, which remains the single, detailed source of
truth introduced in 9b42a40a2a.
See gh-36997
This commit adds a "Lifecycle and Reuse" section to the SpEL reference
documentation, immediately following the security considerations
introduced for gh-36997, explaining that AST nodes within a parsed
Expression may cache resolved PropertyAccessor, IndexAccessor,
MethodExecutor, and ConstructorExecutor instances for performance.
We also now document that reusing a parsed Expression across
EvaluationContext instances of the same type and with equivalent
configuration is supported (even if atypical), including when accessors
or resolvers registered with a context change between evaluations, but
that reusing a parsed Expression across contexts with different
security implications (for example, first against a
StandardEvaluationContext and later against a SimpleEvaluationContext)
is not supported, since cached state from a more permissive evaluation
may be reused during a more restrictive one.
The Javadoc for Expression, SpelExpression, EvaluationContext,
StandardEvaluationContext, SimpleEvaluationContext, PropertyAccessor,
IndexAccessor, MethodExecutor, and ConstructorExecutor has also been
updated to make these contracts discoverable via the API as well.
Closes gh-36968
This commit clarifies in the Javadoc for EvaluationContext,
StandardEvaluationContext, and SimpleEvaluationContext (as well as in
the SpEL reference documentation) that StandardEvaluationContext must
never be used to evaluate expressions from an untrusted source, and
that SimpleEvaluationContext's restricted language and feature subset
is only a best-effort measure. The updated documentation also defines a
"trusted" source as a developer or administrator of the application and
points out that it is the responsibility of the code that configures an
EvaluationContext to ensure that no object reachable via the context
exposes dangerous operations.
Closes gh-36997
Prior to this commit, the SpEL Indexer's PropertyAccessorValueRef could
reuse a cached PropertyAccessor for reads and writes even after that
accessor had been removed from the current EvaluationContext, leading
to stale property access if the EvaluationContext changes between
evaluations of the same expression.
This commit aligns PropertyAccessorValueRef with the analogous logic
in PropertyOrFieldReference and Indexer's IndexAccessorValueRef by
verifying that the cached PropertyAccessor is still registered in the
current EvaluationContext before reusing it in getValue() and
setValue().
Closes gh-36986
Prior to this commit, a SpEL ConstructorReference could reuse a cached
ConstructorExecutor even when the current EvaluationContext no longer
had any registered ConstructorResolvers, leading to inconsistent
behavior if the EvaluationContext changes between evaluations of the
same expression.
This commit aligns ConstructorReference with the analogous logic in
PropertyOrFieldReference by discarding the cached ConstructorExecutor
whenever there are no ConstructorResolvers registered in the current
EvaluationContext, ensuring that constructor resolution consistently
fails with a CONSTRUCTOR_NOT_FOUND exception in that scenario.
Closes gh-36985
Prior to this commit, SpEL's InlineList was cached as a mutable list in
compiled mode (i.e., in a static field in the generated byte code).
To address that, this commit modifies InlineList's generateClinitCode()
method so that it wraps both top-level and nested inline lists using
Collections.unmodifiableList(), analogous to what we already do in
createList().
Closes gh-37001
This commit introduces support for tracking operations during SpEL
expression evaluation. If the maximum number of operations is exceeded,
a SpelEvaluationException is thrown.
The limit can be configured either on a per-use-case basis via
SpelParserConfiguration supplied to the SpelExpressionParser or
globally as a JVM system property or Spring property named
`spring.expression.maxOperations`.
Closes gh-36801
In Spring Framework 7.0, we introduced support for using `Optional`
with the null-safe and Elvis operators in SpEL expressions; however,
such expressions were previously not compilable.
To address that, this commit introduces a new
insertOptionalUnwrapIfNecessary() method in CodeFlow which effectively
inserts byte code instructions for `myOptional.orElse(null)`, and the
Elvis, Indexer, MethodReference, and PropertyOrFieldReference
implementations have been modified to track the need to unwrap an
`Optional` in compiled mode and delegate to
insertOptionalUnwrapIfNecessary() accordingly.
See gh-20433
See gh-36331
Closes gh-36330
Prior to this commit, we invoked `Class.getName()` when building error
messages during annotation processing, resulting in exceptions like the
following which use binary names for nested types and arrays.
Attribute 'chars' in annotation
org.springframework.core.annotation.AnnotationUtilsTests$CharsContainer
should be compatible with [C but a [I value was returned
This commit switches to canonical names in error messages in annotation
processing, resulting in improved such errors messages such as the
following.
Attribute 'chars' in annotation
org.springframework.core.annotation.AnnotationUtilsTests.CharsContainer
should be compatible with char[] but a int[] value was returned
In addition, this commit introduces a new getCanonicalName(Class) method
in ClassUtils, which has effectively been extracted from the following
classes where this functionality was previously duplicated.
- AttributeMethods
- SynthesizedMergedAnnotationInvocationHandler
- TypeDescriptor
- DefaultRetryPolicy
- ReflectiveIndexAccessor
Closes gh-36607
Although this commit also changes the visibility of some test methods
to package-private, the remainder of that task will be addressed in
conjunction with gh-36496.
Closes gh-36495
Sam Brannen
Yanming Zhou
shenjianeng